Reviews

Is GTA VI Worth Playing? Reviews Give It a 99 on Metacritic

Pixel Wizard 5 min read

Yes — if the reviews are any guide, Grand Theft Auto VI is the best-reviewed game of all time. Rockstar’s sequel launched to a 99 on Metacritic, matching The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time as the joint-highest score in the site’s history, with an OpenCritic average of 98 and 100% of critics recommending it. It goes on sale tomorrow, November 19, on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S.

The review embargo lifted this morning, and the verdict has been about as close to unanimous as a game this big ever gets. More than 100 critic reviews counted at the embargo lift — every single one positive — and the board has only grown since, without a single mixed or negative score joining it. Here’s what the critics are actually saying, what the scores mean, and the one caveat worth knowing before you buy.

The scoreboard

The headline number is the 99 Metascore on PlayStation 5, built on 100-plus critic reviews. That puts GTA VI above every game Rockstar has ever made: Grand Theft Auto IV held the studio record at 98, while Grand Theft Auto V and Red Dead Redemption 2 both sit at 97. The Xbox version is tracking at 99 as well, from a smaller pool of reviews. Over on OpenCritic, the Top Critic Average is 98, with every critic recommending the game.

The perfect scores piled up fast. IGN awarded a 10/10, with reviewer Luke Reilly — who played for three weeks and more than 120 hours — calling it “the single most impressive video game I have ever played.” GamesRadar, Eurogamer, The Guardian, and Video Games Chronicle all gave it 5/5. Edge awarded a 100. Game Informer, Vice, and Forbes all handed out perfect scores too, with Forbes’ Paul Tassi writing that he’s “not sure anyone will ever be able to make a game like this again.” Bloomberg called it a “masterpiece.”

The lowest score on the board so far is an 80 from ScreenHub, which gave it four stars out of five and found that it didn’t immediately live up to the hype. That’s the closest thing to a dissenting voice in the first wave — and even that review is a recommendation.

What the critics agree on

Three things come up in almost every review. First, the world: Vice City and the wider state of Leonida are being described as the most detailed open world ever built, with reviewers repeatedly reaching for superlatives about the density of the place — the crowds, the lighting at sunset, the way the city feels alive even when you’re doing nothing at all. VGC called it the most remarkable open world ever built, and that line, in one wording or another, shows up across the board.

Second, the leads. Jason and Lucia, the dual protagonists at the center of a Bonnie-and-Clyde-style story, are drawing praise as a pair — Edge aimed its highest praise at their relationship, and several reviewers singled out the emotional weight of the central love story as the thing that separates this from a mere technical showcase.

Third, the scale of the ambition. GameSpot, after more than 60 hours, called it a game of staggering scope. The Guardian wrote that Rockstar has “created the most extraordinarily, indulgently detailed virtual world that we have yet seen.” The through-line in the reviews is that this is a game that tries to do everything, and mostly pulls it off.

The one real caveat: 30fps, everywhere

If there’s a complaint that keeps coming back, it’s the frame rate. Rockstar confirmed on November 10 that GTA VI targets 30 frames per second on every console, PlayStation 5 Pro included, with no performance mode on offer. The Pro spends its extra power on PSSR upscaling and ray-traced shadows instead. Push Square named the 30fps cap the game’s biggest downside, and GameSpot noted frame dips only at the extreme end of a six-star police chase.

For most players this will be a non-issue — the reviews make clear the game looks extraordinary at 30fps — but if you’re sensitive to frame rate, or you bought a PS5 Pro specifically hoping for a 60fps mode, go in with eyes open. The Verge also flagged some clunky combat mechanics and minor bugs, though it still concluded the game “lives up to the hype.”

What you need to know before launch

  • Release: Thursday, November 19, at midnight local time, on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S.
  • Price: $79.99 for the Standard Edition, $99.99 for the Ultimate Edition, which adds in-game content.
  • PC: Rockstar has not announced a PC version. Every review so far is based on console builds.
  • Preload: Digital preload opened November 10, with the game taking up to 212GB depending on platform.
  • Story length: Reports suggest a story of roughly 50 hours across around 100 missions, though Rockstar hasn’t confirmed a figure.

Thirteen years after Grand Theft Auto V, the sequel arrives carrying the weight of the most anticipated launch in the medium’s history — and, on the evidence of the first reviews, carrying it well. The scores can still move as later reviews land, and the user scores will tell their own story once players get their hands on it tomorrow. But the critical verdict is already historic: a 99, a clean sweep of positive reviews, and a game that reviewers keep calling the most impressive they’ve ever played.

If you were waiting for a reason to pick it up, the critics just handed you one. If you were waiting for a reason to hold off, the only honest one is the frame rate — and even the reviewers who flagged it still gave the game top marks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *